Tuesday, July 12, 2011
The Mohammad Al-Amin Mosque, located in Martyrs' Square in downtown Beirut, Lebanon. Photo courtesy of Julie Payne.
The following three articles were written by Alice Klein, the co-founder, Editor and CEO of Now Magazine
, one of Canada's longest-running free alternative newsweeklies. She wrote them while in Beirut, Lebanon, for the IFEX Strategy Conference from May 30 to June 3, 2011.
As one of CJFE's Board members, Alice travelled with CJFE's President Arnold Amber, Executive Director Annie Game and Manager Julie Payne to take part in the biennial meeting of the world's largest network of free expression organizations.
1. My Iraq chat in Beirut
2. Revolution rewind
3. Up close with Journaliste en danger
Read more articles from IFEX members about the Conference here
Okay, I’m shallow. But meeting Bashar Al-Mandalawy, the first thing I notice is how cool he looks. He’d be so at home on Queen West. But actually, he lives in Baghdad — born and bred — and there’s little comfort in that.
Being here in Beirut with an international phalanx of human rights leaders is just a short reprieve. He works full-tilt for the Journalistic Freedoms Observatory
and the way he quietly says he’s seen a lot, speaks volumes.
Right now, the worries are piling up.
Just last February — the 23rd at 2 AM to be exact — his office was broken into. Thankfully no one was there at the time. The computers were all taken and most of the paper archives also. “They now have all our information,” he says with a worried look. He feels certain the order came directly from the Prime Minister.
The docs are critical because one of their main activities involves fighting with and in the courts. A big case right now involves defending the executive director of his group, also the head of the city’s media college, who uncovered ministry corruption related to the building of a sports stadium in Baghdad. The minister responded by fining the professor $1 billion dinar.
For now, they have moved to what he describes as a “safe house.” They don’t bring any visitors to the office, so he feels that no one in the area knows who they are — which is how they like it. And through the setbacks the organization is stronger now, he says. They observe violations and they are able offer help to journalists all over the country who need lawyers for advice and protection.
But Al-Mandalawy thinks the biggest threat these days is Iran who, through the Shia Al-Mahdi Army and the leader Mahdi Al-Sadr, have a lot of power in Parliament, controlling six or seven Ministries. And the Sadrists pull on the streets. Just last week, a demo in Baghdad’s Sadr City area gathered the city’s Shia in uncountable numbers. Press reports vary from 70,000 to 700,000. Al-Mandawaly says they marched in the millions.
It is all too much. Sadly and happily, Mandawaly plans to leave Iraq within the next year. It is too dangerous and now that he has a son (just three months old), he feels he must find a better life for his family. Not the best for Baghdad but…
Image: Bashar Al-Mandalawy from the Journalistic Freedoms Observatory.
We’re talking revolution in Egypt, and pessimism and optimism are duking it out. For these couple of hours, a hotel meeting room in Beirut is the forum for a handful of Egypt’s human rights luminaries to assess the trajectory of their country’s chaos.
I am at the general meeting of the International Freedom of Expression Exchange
(IFEX). Catchy titles have never been the strong point of civil society groups, but don’t let the boring monicker fool you.
If the global human rights firing line were Hollywood, pretty much everyone here would be walking the red carpet (myself excluded). All present stand up for critical speech against great odds in Uganda, Sri Lanka, Mexico, Congo, Yemen – you name it.
And there’s something for Canada to crow about here, because this networked group of freedom front-liners is tended and nurtured between meets by their Canuck member, Canadian Journalists for Free Expression. I’m one of them, which is how I got my place at the table.
But this session is for Egypt’s media rights leaders, and there are many threads to untangle. Does that country’s army have its own agenda? Will the masses stay engaged? And ominously at this confab of journalistic free expression defenders, will big-monied media be reborn as a vehicle for any of several possible counter-revolutionary scenarios?
Renowned blogger and journalist Nora Younis is the pessimist at the table. She was right there back in 2004 when web activism went beyond the chat room. While pundits hail Egypt’s internet uprising, Younis recalls how effectively state repression kept up. Now, in Egypt, the prime minister has a Twitter account, and the army exclusively uses Facebook for all its announcements.
Writing the word “military” isn’t against the law as it was before the revolution, but researching the misdeeds of the army is beyond touchy. One real danger Younis sees is that the “structures for defending press freedom aren’t yet there,” though, as a member of the new National Coalition for Media Freedom
, she is certainly working on it. The soft launch of the org’s website just went up on Monday, June 5.
Gamal Eid, veteran lead defence lawyer in many of Egypt’s most important human rights cases, says current violations “even exceed what we experienced before the revolution.” Yet he’s pulling for the optimist side; the army, he says, reacts positively to public pressure.
The army’s special place in the nation’s psyche is a recurring theme, and Eid has come up with an interesting strategy to address this fact. In his current campaign, he encourages bloggers and journalists to criticize the military tribunals (in which protesters are tried) in a pro-army context.
“We differentiate between the army and the military tribunals so it doesn’t hurt the credibility of the army,” he says. It has been a success, and Eid is undaunted by the fact that 20 or 25 per cent of critics get hauled in for questioning. In a post-dictator period, everything is relative.
In fact, the defence lawyer feels that one of the problems for civil society is that the most important organizations on the ground are geared to confrontation when the situation calls for conversation and dialogue. “Some of my friends would be surprised to hear me say we have a good interior minister,” he says.
Journalist Khaled Al-Sergany sees the situation similarly and says that when sitting in on tribunals, one can witness the uncertainty of officers. “We can’t turn the government and the military into enemies,” he says. “We need to work with them and listen to them.”
Appeal lawyer Rawda Ahmed concurs, saying that because the situation is so unresolved, it’s important to be in process with authorities. Her organization was invited by the minister of communication to discuss new media laws and regulations. At the end of the conversation, in which Eid also participated, the minister confided that he didn’t know whether to push ahead in Parliament or wait until the election.
They suggested that he publish the proposed law on the internet and solicit comments. To their surprise, that’s what he did. Don’t get Eid wrong, though. He is clear that every member of civil society must keep one foot in Tahrir Square and one in the office.
Sherif Azer of the Egyptian Organization for Human Rights
, a younger activist who remembers the military mentality from his own army days, is also not fearful about the military’s political weight. “They are very sensitive to protests and criticism,” he says. “Once people are on the streets and there is a campaign against one of their decisions, they’ll withdraw that decision.”
But there’s the rub. Younis is not sure activists will be able to mobilize endlessly. Sentiments are changing, she feels, and the populace is getting tired of the atmosphere of upheaval. The revolution needs to deliver something that really makes a difference.
Take the minimum wage. Demonstrators asked for a raise to 1,200 pounds from the current 150, she points out, but the minister of finance raised it only to 700 a month. As well, the uprising “gave a hard fist to the police,” but there is no police reform, and, says Younis, there is a security vacuum, so people will be begging for their presence.
And what role will the non-state mainstream media that is reconfiguring itself play in forming public opinion? Big dollars are heading for satellite channels. The perception in Egypt is that Gulf money is going there, says Younis, and many channels are in the offing before there is a process for vetting, transparency and a code of ethics. That is a much bigger worry at the table than radical Islam.
“Islamists are part of our society,” says Eid, “but not the majority.” He feels the worry is a Western fixation. Last Friday, June 3, the Muslim Brotherhood and military council tried to pressure people to stop the Friday protests, he says. Instead, a million came out to support civil society and democracy.
Younis’s caution is really smart, but so is Eid’s hopefulness, which is far from blind. They all expect the revolution will unfold for years to come. And yet, at the same time, every minute counts.
Despite their differing assessments, panelists agree on the role of international assistance. Eid would like to see organizations working with the European Commission become aware of Egypt’s issues so that when the EU talks to Egyptian officials, human rights can be raised.
But there are straightforward needs, too. Younis sums them up as exchange and translation – translation into Arabic not only of laws and books, but also of films, most of which are available only in English or Spanish. “Docs appeal to the younger generation,” she says, and translation “will influence not only Egyptians, but the rest of the Arab world as well.”
No one knows how the process will unfold. Reform is working in parallel with the traditional political process – sometimes very fast, sometimes slow. “We need to be working in tandem on many things. We need to be ready,” says Eid.
EGYPT WISH LIST
The transitional government of Egypt should:
• Abolish the Emergency Law, which allows authorities to detain people without charge.
• Rescind the new strike and demonstration law, which bans protests that “obstruct” state institutions.
• Abolish penal code provisions on “insulting public authorities’’ and “spreading false information.”
• Revoke the Assembly Law, which requires gatherings to disperse if ordered by authorities.
• Amend the Associations Law to allow NGOs to be established without government approval.
• Establish civilian oversight of the police force.
• Stop trying civilians in military courts.
From Human Rights Reform An Urgent Priority, Human Rights Watch, June 7
Image: Egyptian colleagues Gamal Eid and Rawda Ahmed from of the Arabic Network for Human Rights Information and Sherif Azer from Egyptian Organization for Human Rights.
I’m at the IFEX business meeting and the Crown Plaza Hotel setting, the well-ordered agenda and calm discussion are all good. But the spirit of what’s really going on here lives in the intense gaze that sits above the ready smile of Congolese journalist Tshivis Tshivuadi.
Somewhere else on the planet, destiny might have had a softer life in mind for the talented professional who went from j-school to editor of the largest Khinsasa daily in less than a decade back in the 90s. Hopes were high when he started the job just after the cleptocrat-dictator Mobutu got booted out of Zaire in 1997 and a new leader was promising to earn the country’s recovered name, the Democratic Republic of Congo.
The back-tracking on that promise was swift. Another long cycle of repression was about to begin and Tshivuadi became one of the first victims of the new dictator. After a critical article denouncing the raising of tribal armies, Tshivuadi’s publisher was thrown in jail and he was forced to head underground right away. It was a dark period with no contact with family or friends. Tshivuadi felt completely abandoned and alone. Eventually his publisher was released and Tshivuadi was able to return. He immediately gathered a group of friends and in 1998, they launched Journaliste en Danger
, committing to the mission that no case of threats, imprisonment or death against journalists would go unreported. His group have continued monitoring and defending press freedom and facing down the authorities ever since. By the next year, Journaliste en Danger had become a member of IFEX and he says that international relationship is what gave his org the clout to be heard. “By joining IFEX, we gained respect and credibility,” he says. “It makes our enemies cautious.”
But until recently, there were still many attacks. JED staff were targeted with death threats and they went into hiding repeatedly – never knowing how long it would last or what would happen.
Officials regularly accuse his organization of representing Western interests and acting against the state by selling a poor image of the country.
A year ago, a well-known human rights activist and a good friend was killed while in custody. This was the one person that had helped Tshivuadi find his way when he was forced underground. His death had a chilling effect.
Unlike past years, there are currently no journalists in jail in the Congo, Tshivuadi explains. But not because measures are in place to guarantee against impunity. Instead, newspapers have stopped reporting on corruption and violence.
“They stay out of trouble. Because of gross repression and the will to survive, journalists have ceased to play the role of watchdog. The national and local media have lost all credibility with the population,” he says. People got to international sources to find out what’s going on. But none of this is stopping Tshivuadi from the pleasure of a coffee break chat at the conference here in Beirut. And it isn’t stopping his work when he gets back home either.
Image: IFEX members in Beirut, Lebanon.